Reverse mortgages allow Canadian homeowners aged 55 and over to access some of the equity in their home as a lump sum payment or series of payments. With Canada’s aging population, reverse mortgages are becoming an increasingly popular option, which allows Canadian homeowners aged 55 and over to access their home equity.

However, reverse mortgages also have potential downsides, which have fueled horror stories and myths about the products. As a borrower, it’s essential to understand the realities behind these stories to make an informed decision.

This extensive guide will examine reverse mortgage horror stories in the Canadian context. We aim to bring clarity, sanity, and facts to the discussion of these stories in Canada. Let’s dive in.

Background of Reverse Mortgage Horror Stories

The vast majority of widely circulated online reverse mortgage horror stories originate from the United States. This relates to the less stringent historical regulation of the industry there compared to Canada.

For instance, in the 1990s, U.S. legislative changes allowed American lenders to sell reverse mortgages to third parties as investments. This incentivized lenders to issue as many reverse mortgages as possible and introduced new players to the market who employed aggressive sales tactics.

(Source: https://www.investopedia.com/reverse-mortgages-canada-vs-usa-5223723)

In contrast, Canada does not have a market for private mortgage-backed securities of this nature. Canadian lenders have less incentive to resort to predatory practices to boost volumes.

Canadian and U.S. Reverse Mortgage: Key Differences

The differences between the Canadian and U.S. reverse mortgage markets are important to consider when assessing the applicability of American-based horror stories. Many do not translate directly to the Canadian context, with its more tightly regulated market and built-in consumer protections.

Maximum Loan Amounts

In Canada, reverse mortgage borrowers can access up to 55% of their home’s value. This more conservative limit aims to help borrowers maintain equity in their homes. In contrast, in the U.S., borrowers can access up to 60% of the home’s appraised value.

Eligibility Requirements

Canadian reverse mortgages have strict eligibility requirements. All borrowers must be aged 55 or older. In the U.S., eligibility ranges from age 62 to 65, depending on the lender. The lower age limit in Canada makes reverse mortgages accessible to more retirees.

Independent Legal Advice Required

In Canada, reverse mortgage lenders require borrowers to seek independent legal advice before taking out a reverse mortgage. This ensures borrowers understand the terms and implications. No such mandatory legal consultation is required in the U.S.

Fees and Closing Costs

Canadian lenders charge lower upfront fees and closing costs than the U.S. market. For example, mortgage insurance premiums and sizeable origination fees are required in the U.S. but not in Canada.

Limited Lenders in Canada with More Oversight

Canada has just two federally regulated reverse mortgage lenders, HomeEquity Bank and Equitable Bank, and some smaller lenders like Bloom and Fractioncompared to hundreds in the fragmented U.S. market. With fewer players, there is increased oversight and less aggressive competition.

Read more: Major Reverse Mortgage Lenders in Canada

• CHIP Reverse Mortgage
• Equitable Bank Reverse Mortgage
• Bloom Reverse Mortgage

Tax Differences

In the U.S., reverse mortgage advances may be partially taxable under some circumstances. In Canada, reverse mortgages provide tax-free cash that does not affect government benefits.

Analyzing Horror Stories Critically

Whenever assessing anecdotes or reports involving reverse mortgages, it’s wise to ask critical questions, such as:

• Does this story originate from the U.S. or Canada?
• How old is this information? Have regulations and practices changed since?
• What specific product, lender, or period does this relate to?
• Does the story reflect the borrower’s unique circumstances more than issues with reverse mortgages?
• Is there another side to this story that adds context?
• Who is sharing this information, and what is their agenda? Are they qualified to assess reverse mortgages conclusively?

Asking these questions will typically reveal that while the stories hold some truth, the full picture is far more nuanced. Blanket avoidance of reverse mortgages based on horror stories is seldom warranted.

Canadian Reverse Mortgage Horror Stories: Truth or Myth?

It is important to understand that many horror stories stem from outdated situations, misconceptions, or atypical cases that fail to reflect current reverse mortgage realities. Outdated stories often circulate without vital context about evolved regulations and practices. This misleadingly paints past problems as applicable today when that is frequently untrue. In essence, dated stories lack the nuance to judge current products yet continue circulating widely.

Let’s explore some of the most common themes in Canadian reverse mortgage horror stories and the realities behind them.

Unexpected Costs and Fees

One prevalent theme is that borrowers face unexpectedly high fees and costs associated with their reverse mortgage, which can lead to financial hardship.

What’s Behind This?

In the early days of reverse mortgages in Canada, some lenders were not transparent about the fees and compounding interest rates involved. This resulted in the equity in borrowers’ homes being eroded much faster than anticipated in some cases.

The Reality

Thankfully, much has changed. Stringent regulations now require reverse mortgage lenders to disclose all costs and terms to potential borrowers upfront. Standard fees include:

• Appraisal fee: $200 – $500 to assess home value
• Independent legal advice: ~$300 – $800
• Closing costs and lender fees: Up to $2000

While reverse mortgages carry higher interest rates than traditional mortgages, given the unique structure, they are comparable to other home equity lending products. Rates are clearly outlined from the start. With reputable lenders, there are no surprises or hidden fees when taking out a reverse mortgage today in Canada.

Perceived Impact on Heirs

A commonly cited fear is that reverse mortgages leave heirs with little to no equity after the home is sold and the loan repaid after the borrower’s death.

What’s Behind This?

In some early cases, the combination of high fees and compounding interest over many years significantly ate into equity by the time heirs came to sell the home. If home values had also depreciated, this left less for heirs than expected.

The Reality

There are protections in place to ensure heirs inherit a substantial portion of equity, including:

• Lower upfront costs mean less equity erosion.
• Interest stops accruing after a borrower dies, so no further compounding exists.
• Limits prevent the loan from exceeding the home’s fair market value.

In fact, according to HomeEquity Bank, over 95% of borrowers still had equity remaining at the time of repayment. The average equity remaining was over 50% of the home’s value.

Confuse About Terms

Another theme is borrowers misunderstanding terms and implications, sometimes leading to false expectations.

What’s Behind This?

Early reverse mortgage products lacked thorough explanations of the intricacies around ownership, repayment obligations, inheriting the home, and more. Some key misconceptions were

• The bank owns the home after arranging a reverse mortgage (false)
• Repayment only becomes due after the borrower dies (not necessarily true)
• Heirs immediately inherit the home without needing to repay the loan (false)

The Reality

The Canadian government brought in rules in 2014 that require lenders to ensure borrowers grasp terms and implications before signing on the dotted line.

Mandatory independent legal counsel also reduces confusion, as the counsel clearly explains the factors. Reputable lenders also employ staff dedicated to educating borrowers to avoid misunderstandings.

Role of Lenders

Some stories involve borrowers feeling misled or pressured by salespeople or citing unethical lending practices.

What’s Behind This?

In the early 2000s, some questionable third-party lenders entered the Canadian reverse mortgage market, contributing to negative perceptions.

Questionable practices included promoting reverse mortgages to those unsuitable for them or not fully explaining the implications.

The Reality

The market has matured considerably. Today, two highly reputable, federally regulated lenders are HomeEquity Bank and Equitable Bank. Both employ professional advisers obligated to act in borrowers’ best interests. Unethical conduct is grounds for severe penalties.

Comparisons With Alternative Products

Some horror stories arise from reverse mortgages being inappropriately recommended over other products that may have better served the borrower.

What’s Behind This?

Early on, less rigorous processes meant some advisors suggested reverse mortgages when options like traditional home equity loans may have been preferable. This contributed to disappointment for some borrowers.

The Reality

Today, advisors can better compare products across multiple factors relevant to the client’s unique needs. Mandatory independent legal Counsel also provides objective insight into whether alternatives like downsizing or home equity loans could be a better fit.

Strengthened Regulations

A common observation is that tightening regulations have made reverse mortgages safer and more transparent.

What’s Behind This?

Before 2014, Canada’s reverse mortgage industry was predominantly self-regulated, and some lenders took advantage of this lack of oversight. Since 2014, federal regulations require:

• Disclosure of costs, terms, and risks in plain language
• Verifying borrower understanding
• Stringent lending practices
• Adherence to fair treatment of customers

The Reality

These regulations transformed reverse mortgages into one of Canada’s most tightly governed lending products. Borrowers enjoy abundant protections that did not exist previously.

This regulatory overhaul is a major reason why reverse mortgage horror stories in Canada are increasingly outdated and uncommon. While risks exist for newer products issued by reputable lenders, outright horror stories will be few and far between.

Now that we’ve explored the common themes in reverse mortgage horror stories and their attendant realities. Let’s turn our attention to dispelling some of the biggest myths.

Real-Life Reverse Mortgage Horror Stories in Canada

While outdated myths are common, real-life problematic situations involving reverse mortgages in Canada have also occurred. Analyzing actual examples provides important learnings.

Misidentified Home Resulted in Foreclosure

In one concerning case, a lender’s inspector mistakenly visited a vacant restaurant next to a senior’s Alabama home and deemed her actual residence unoccupied, prompting foreclosure proceedings.

This sporadic case exemplifies the importance of diligent lenders and effective communication changes in occupancy status.

Natural Disaster Victim-Faced Foreclosure

An 80-year-old Colorado man lost his home in a wildfire and temporarily moved elsewhere while rebuilding. Despite his unforeseen circumstances, his lender initiated foreclosure since the home was no longer his primary residence, per the loan terms.

This case highlights the value of additional protections for disaster victims and improved lender flexibility.

Fraudulent Contractor Default

A Florida woman used her reverse mortgage funds to hire a contractor for home renovations. When the fraudulent contractor disappeared with the money, she fell ill and failed to pay taxes and insurance, defaulting on her loan.

This example underscores the need for prudent uses of funds and maintaining contingencies to stay current with obligations.

Age Limit Issues for Co-Owners

A Quebec widower was unaware his deceased co-owning wife needed to be over 55 for him to qualify. Upon her death, the lender demanded full loan repayment.

This emphasizes the importance of confirming all co-owners meet eligibility criteria.

While troubling, these cases represent exceptions more than the norm. However, they reinforce the need for borrowers to exercise abundant caution and understand all details before pursuing a reverse mortgage. Sound preparation can help avoid distressing situations.

Key Takeaways on Reverse Mortgage Horror Stories in Canada

Given this comprehensive examination of reverse mortgage horror stories in Canada, what key conclusions can we draw?

• Many stories are outdated or misconstrued, stemming from past industry issues that regulations have largely rectified.
• Reverse mortgages carry risks that warrant consideration. However, outright reverse mortgage horror stories are increasingly uncommon with today’s products.
• The key is choosing reputable Canadian lenders, fully understanding the implications, and using reverse mortgages prudently as part of holistic retirement plans.
• In contrast with the U.S. market and products, more stringent regulations and the maturation of the Canadian industry have made reverse mortgages safer and more transparent than ever.
• While due diligence is still required, blanket avoidance of reverse mortgages based on scary anecdotes is usually unwarranted in Canada today.
• With appropriate precautions, education, and strategic use, reverse mortgages remain effective tools for many Canadian homeowners to fund their retirement goals.

The Bottom Line

With millions of Canadian baby boomers entering retirement, products like reverse mortgages will grow in prominence and require objective assessments. Avoiding knee-jerk reactions based on dated stories and grasping today’s realities will benefit consumers and the industry.

Reverse mortgages can positively enhance many seniors’ retirements. However, as with any complex financial product, education, prudence, and individualized assessments of their merits are key prerequisites. At Best Mortgage Online, our mortgage experts are dedicated to helping Canadian homeowners navigate the complexities of reverse mortgages.

Still not sure if a reverse mortgage is right for you? Contact us today for a consultation and avoid the risks of misinformation.

FAQs

Article Sources

1. Let’s Discuss Reverse Mortgage Horror Stories
2. A look at reverse mortgage horror stories
3. Reverse Mortgage Horror Stories in Canada