Cash-Out Refinance: Benefits, Risks, and Alternatives

A cash-out refinance in Canada, often referred to as an equity takeout refinance, is a type of mortgage refinancing that allows homeowners to leverage the home equity they have built. This involves replacing your existing mortgage with a new, larger one, receiving the difference as a lump sum of cash.

This guide explains cash-out refinancing, including how it works, its requirements, pros and cons, best uses for the cash, alternatives, and more.

What is a Cash-Out Refinance?

How Does a Cash Out Refinance Work
Cash-out refinance is a way to take out home equity through refinancing

A cash-out refinance means you take out a new mortgage loan for more than the amount still owed on your current mortgage, with the extra money above your existing mortgage balance paid out to you in cash.

A cash-out refinance differs from a standard mortgage refinance in that the new mortgage is taken out for the remaining balance owed on the current one. With a cash-out refinance, you intentionally borrow more to withdraw home equity.

How does Cash-out refinancing work?

Here is a step-by-step overview of how a cash-out refinance works in Canada:

Step 1: Calculate your home equity

Your home equity is calculated by taking your home’s current value and subtracting any outstanding mortgage debt tied to the property. This is known as the loan-to-value (LTV) ratio. An appraisal will be required to officially determine the home’s market value.

    Loan-to-Value (LTV) Ratio Explained

    The LTV ratio is a critical factor in determining your eligibility for a cash-out refinance and the interest rate you’ll receive. A lower LTV ratio generally indicates lower risk for the lender, which can translate to more favorable terms. It’s important to maintain a healthy LTV to avoid potential financial strain and protect your home equity.

    Step 2: Determine the maximum loan amount

    Most lenders will let you borrow up to 80% of your home value. However, you can only borrow against the available equity, not including your mortgage balance.

    Step 3: Complete the refinance

    After choosing a lender and loan amount, complete the refinance application process. This process involves documentation, appraisal, credit check, and, potentially, retaking the mortgage stress test.

    Step 4: Receive the cash

    Once approved and closed, your new mortgage will be used to pay off the old one. The difference between the two loan amounts will be paid out to you in cash.

    How Much Cash Can You Access Through a Cash-Out Refinance?

    Most lenders will let you borrow up to 80% of your home’s appraised value through a cash-out refinance. However, you can only tap into your accumulated equity, not counting your current mortgage debt.

    Let’s look at an example:

    • Home value: $500,000
    • Existing mortgage: $300,000
    • Total equity: $200,000

    Since 80% of $500,000 is $400,000, you may qualify to borrow up to this amount. However, when you subtract your current mortgage balance of $300,000, the maximum cash you can take out is $100,000.

    In this scenario, you could refinance into a new $400,000 mortgage and receive $100,000 in your pocket. Just remember the 80% limit is based on your home value, while the actual cash out depends on your built-up equity.

    Cash-Out Refinance vs Standard Refinance: What’s the difference?

    While both are types of mortgage refinancing, there are seven key differences between a cash-out refinance and a standard rate-and-term refinance.

    FactorCash-Out RefinanceStandard Refinance
    Loan AmountBorrowing moreRemaining principal owed
    PurposeAccess home equityChange rate/term
    Monthly PaymentsUsually increaseMaintain or decrease
    Risk LevelHigherLower
    Upfront CostsAppraisal, penaltiesDischarge fees
    Tax ImplicationsNon-taxable cashLower interest rates may lower deductions
    Credit ImpactIncreases debtUtilization unchanged

    In short, the central distinction is that a cash-out refinance intentionally borrows above your current mortgage amount so that you can withdraw equity, while a standard refinance just gets you a new rate and term without taking equity out.

    What are the Pros of Cash-out Refinance?

    There are 4 main benefits of a Cash-out Refinance

    • Access larger loan amounts: Borrow more than you could with a personal loan or line of credit.
    • Lower interest rates: Mortgage rates are generally lower than other financing options.
    • Consolidate debts: Pay off higher-interest debts like credit cards or loans.
    • Improve credit: Reducing high credit utilization can help boost your score.

    Drawbacks of Cash-Out Refinance

    Cash-out refinancing offers potential benefits but also downsides. Carefully weigh the pros and cons based on your specific financial situation.

    • Increased mortgage amount: Your housing debt and monthly payments will go up.
    • Interest costs: You’ll pay more interest over the life of a larger loan.
    • Closing costs and fees: Refinancing comes with upfront costs.
    • Foreclosure risk: Not making larger payments could risk foreclosure.

    How Do You Qualify for a Cash-Out Refinance?

    How to qualify for a Cash-Out Refinance in Canada
    5 eligibility criteria for cash-out refinance in Canada

    To qualify for a cash-out refinance mortgage, you will need to meet specific eligibility criteria:

    • Home equity: Have at least 20% equity built up in your home. The more equity you have, the more cash you can potentially take out.
    • Credit score: Most lenders recommend a minimum credit score of 650, but those with higher scores will qualify for better interest rates.
    • Income and debt levels: Your gross income must be stable and sufficient to support the higher mortgage payments. Many lenders look for a gross debt service ratio below 50% and a total debt service ratio under 50% to approve borrowers.
    • Appraisal: The lender will require a current appraisal to be completed on the home to confirm its updated fair market value and calculate how much equity is available to borrow against.
    • Mortgage stress test: If refinancing with a federally regulated lender, you’ll likely need to undergo another stress test to ensure you can still afford payments at a higher rate.

    To qualify for a cash-out refinance, you must meet standard mortgage loan approval criteria. Improving your credit score, reducing debts, and stabilizing income sources will help you meet these requirements.

    Best Uses for Cash-Out Refinance Funds

    The proceeds from a cash-out refinance are yours to spend or invest as you wish. However, some uses make more financial sense than others when weighed against the risks of borrowing more. Here are some of the wisest ways to utilize cash-out mortgage funds:

    • Home renovations or improvements: Remodelling, upgrades or repairs can increase your property value, recouping some or all of your investment.
    • Pay off high-interest debts: Consolidating credit card, loan or line of credit balances into your lower mortgage rate can save substantially on interest.
    • Start or expand a business: Inject capital into starting a new business or expanding an existing one. Be sure to have a solid business plan.
    • Real estate investments: Use them as a down payment on rental properties or for fixing and flipping houses. Perform due diligence on profit potential.
    • Education expenses: Pay for vocational training, college tuition, or continuing education to improve income potential.
    • Major medical procedures: Use funds to undergo a medically necessary procedure not fully covered by insurance.
    • Consumption spending: While less ideal, cash-outs may help fund large purchases, vacations, or basic expenses in a financial pinch.

    Avoid tapping home equity just to fund an unsustainable lifestyle. Instead, look for opportunities to use the capital to generate potential returns or future cost savings.

    What are Alternatives to Cash-Out Refinancing?

    What are Alternatives to Cash-Out Refinancing
    Explore the alternatives to cash-out refinancing before deciding

    Other home equity borrowing options besides a cash-out refinance include:

    • Home equity loan: Provide a lump sum of cash. You’ll receive funds upfront and repay the home equity loan through fixed installments over a set term. The loan is secured by your home, meaning missed payments give the lender the right to foreclose.
    • Second mortgage: An additional loan to your existing first mortgage that helps access up to 80% of your home value minus your first mortgage balance.
    • HELOC: A revolving line of credit secured by your home’s equity. You can draw funds as needed up to your approved limit and repay on your schedule.

    These alternatives have pros and cons. Shop for the best rates and terms for your needs and financial situation.

    FAQs about Cash-Out Refinance in Canada

    No schema found.

    Cash-out refinancing can be a strategic way to tap into your home’s equity if used responsibly. While tempting, it is critical to consider both the benefits and risks before withdrawing cash. Analyze your financial situation carefully, create a repayment plan, and use funds wisely to generate returns. For personalized guidance, connect with a qualified mortgage broker to discuss your options.

    Article Sources
    1. What Is A Cash-Out Refinance In Canada?- loanscanada.ca
    2. Refinancing Your Mortgage – rbcroyalbank.com